Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation instead of surgery: when can it help?
Does a torn meniscus need surgery? Do shoulder pain and disc problems mean an operation is inevitable? Research shows that, in some cases, appropriate rehabilitation can produce outcomes comparable to surgery. Some studies have even found that selected surgical procedures offer no additional benefit over sham surgery.
Updated
9 min read
Written by Forma, Editorial team

Imagine your knee has been hurting for several months. You have an MRI scan, and the report says “meniscus tear”.
Your first thought might be: if something is damaged, it needs to be repaired.
But pain and changes seen on imaging do not always have a straightforward relationship. Not every finding requires surgery, and not every operation produces better outcomes than non-surgical care.
Let’s look at what the research actually shows.
Can rehabilitation replace surgery?
Yes, rehabilitation can be an effective alternative to surgery for some conditions. These include many degenerative meniscus tears, certain shoulder pain syndromes and some cases of back pain.
That does not mean exercise is always enough.
The decision depends on the type of injury, symptoms, overall health, the patient’s goals and the expected benefits of each treatment.
Which problems may benefit from rehabilitation?
Scroll the table horizontally to see all columns.
| Problem | Role of rehabilitation | When might surgery be needed? |
|---|---|---|
| Degenerative meniscus tear | An appropriate first treatment in many cases | Selected unstable tears or a genuinely locked knee |
| Persistent subacromial shoulder pain | Exercise therapy may provide improvement comparable to decompression | Some traumatic tendon tears and other distinct conditions |
| Non-specific low back pain | Activity and exercise are important parts of treatment | Specific conditions that require surgery |
| Disc problems with sciatica | Non-surgical care is often the first approach | Selected cases of persistent severe symptoms or neurological deficits |
| Knee osteoarthritis | Exercise improves function and may reduce pain | Substantial limitations despite appropriate non-surgical care |
Each situation needs an individual assessment. The following sections examine the evidence.
A torn meniscus: surgery or rehabilitation?
The menisci are structures inside the knee that help distribute loads and stabilise the joint.
A meniscus tear can happen during a sudden injury, but it can also develop gradually through degeneration.
This distinction matters. Findings about degenerative tears should not automatically be applied to acute sports injuries.
What did the ESCAPE trial find?
The randomised ESCAPE trial compared two treatments for degenerative meniscus tears:
- Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, which removes part of the meniscus surgically.
- Physiotherapy based on progressive exercise.
The trial enrolled 321 people aged 45–70.
At five years, rehabilitation was non-inferior to surgery for patient-reported knee function, within the trial’s predefined margin.
Both groups improved substantially.
In practice, appropriately delivered physiotherapy may be the preferred first treatment for many people with a degenerative meniscus tear.
This does not mean exercise will heal every torn meniscus. Improvements in symptoms and function are different from complete structural healing.
Source: Noorduyn et al., ESCAPE, JAMA Network Open, 2022.
Sham surgery: can patients improve without the key surgical step?
This is one of the most interesting questions in modern orthopaedic research.
Drug trials use placebos, which do not contain the active ingredient being studied.
A similar approach can be used in surgery.
In sham-surgery trials, some patients undergo a control procedure that leaves out the operation’s key therapeutic step.
Participants give informed consent beforehand to the possibility of being assigned to this group.
The FIDELITY trial: meniscus surgery versus sham surgery
The Finnish FIDELITY trial examined arthroscopic partial removal of a degeneratively torn meniscus.
Patients were randomly assigned to two groups.
In one group, the surgeon removed part of the meniscus. In the other, the surgeon performed arthroscopy but left out the meniscus-removal step.
Patients did not know which group they had been assigned to.
At five years, the researchers found no relevant additional benefit from partial meniscus removal for the symptoms and knee function assessed.
The meniscectomy group also showed slightly greater progression of osteoarthritic changes on X-rays.
The trial involved a specific group of patients with degenerative meniscus tears. It does not show that surgery is ineffective for every type of meniscus tear.
Source: Sihvonen et al., FIDELITY, British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2020.
Why do sham-surgery results matter?
These trials show that improvement after surgery does not always come from its key surgical step.
The natural course of the condition, patient expectations, changes in activity, rehabilitation and other aspects of care may also contribute.
However, improvement after sham surgery cannot be attributed entirely to the placebo effect.
The central question is whether a particular surgical step adds benefit beyond the other aspects of care.
Shoulder pain: when might rehabilitation replace surgery?
Persistent shoulder pain can make it difficult to raise your arm, get dressed, exercise or sleep on the affected side.
For many years, some patients underwent arthroscopic subacromial decompression, intended to create more space around certain structures in the shoulder.
Researchers set out to test whether the procedure offered additional improvement.
The FIMPACT trial: results after 10 years
The FIMPACT trial compared:
- Arthroscopic subacromial decompression.
- Sham surgery, consisting of diagnostic arthroscopy without decompression.
- Exercise therapy.
In the ten-year follow-up published in 2025, decompression offered no additional benefit over sham surgery or exercise therapy for the outcomes studied.
Participants in all three groups reported substantial improvement in symptoms.
This does not mean exercise can replace every shoulder operation. The findings apply to a specific pain syndrome and a specific procedure.
Surgery may still be appropriate for some traumatic tendon tears or other conditions.
Source: Kanto et al., FIMPACT, BMJ, 2025.
Disc problems and back pain: can surgery be avoided?
Low back pain is one of the most common musculoskeletal health problems.
An MRI report may mention findings such as a “protrusion”, “disc herniation” or “degenerative changes”.
Imaging findings alone do not determine whether surgery is needed.
Does exercise help with back pain?
For non-specific low back pain, the UK’s NICE guidelines recommend supporting self-management, continuing normal activities and considering an appropriate exercise programme.
The aim is to rebuild function gradually and adapt activity to the person’s abilities.
What about a herniated disc?
A herniated disc does not always require surgery. Some people’s symptoms improve with non-surgical care, and some herniations may partially shrink over time.
However, local back pain is different from severe nerve-root pain, progressive muscle weakness or other neurological deficits.
An appropriate clinical assessment is therefore needed before choosing treatment.
Source: NICE NG59, Low back pain and sciatica in over 16s.
Additional source on spontaneous disc regression: Kesikburun et al., 2019.
Knee osteoarthritis: exercise or a knee replacement?
Knee osteoarthritis can cause pain, stiffness and difficulty walking, climbing stairs or taking part in sport.
But a diagnosis of osteoarthritis does not mean a knee replacement is needed immediately.
NICE guideline NG226 recommends therapeutic exercise tailored to people with osteoarthritis, including strengthening and aerobic activity.
Regular exercise may reduce pain and improve function.
Can rehabilitation rebuild joint cartilage?
Exercise should not be presented as a way to restore damaged cartilage.
The main aims of rehabilitation are to improve strength, function and tolerance of loading, and to reduce symptoms.
When pain and limitations substantially affect quality of life and appropriate non-surgical care is ineffective or unsuitable, a consultation about joint replacement may be worth considering.
Source: NICE NG226, Osteoarthritis in over 16s.
Why can rehabilitation help even when structural damage remains?
An MRI scan is not a precise measure of pain intensity.
Symptoms depend on many factors, including tissue health, nervous-system sensitivity, current loading, physical fitness and sleep.
Rehabilitation may improve function by:
- Increasing muscle strength and endurance.
- Gradually building tolerance of loading.
- Improving movement control and coordination.
- Rebuilding confidence in activity.
- Reducing pain and limitations in everyday life.
Treatment does not always require eliminating every change seen on imaging.
In many situations, a realistic goal is to walk, run, play sport or manage everyday activities again with less pain.
When might rehabilitation be insufficient and surgery necessary?
Rehabilitation cannot replace every operation.
Surgery may be needed for some unstable fractures, acute injuries, certain tendon tears, advanced osteoarthritis and specific neurological conditions.
Seek urgent medical help for symptoms such as new bladder or bowel problems alongside neurological symptoms, loss of sensation around the genitals or perineum, or rapidly progressive limb weakness.
Do not decide to postpone a recommended operation on your own.
Source on urgent assessment of neurological symptoms: NICE NG127.
What does rehabilitation involve before deciding on surgery?
If a doctor confirms that non-surgical care is appropriate, an individual rehabilitation programme may form the basis of treatment.
This usually involves assessing symptoms and movement abilities, selecting exercises, gradually increasing loads and reviewing progress.
No single exercise routine is suitable for every patient.
For example, rehabilitation for a degenerative meniscus tear may focus on lower-limb strength, movement control and tolerance of activities such as squatting or climbing stairs.
For persistent subacromial shoulder pain, a programme may include progressive exercises for the shoulder and shoulder-girdle muscles.
The priorities are an appropriate assessment, consistency and adapting exercise to the person’s response.
Common questions about rehabilitation instead of surgery
Can a torn meniscus heal without surgery?
Healing depends on the type and location of the tear and the blood supply to that part of the meniscus. Some tears can heal; others cannot. Symptoms may also improve even when the structural change remains.
Can a herniated disc shrink without surgery?
Yes, a herniated disc can shrink spontaneously in some patients. This does not happen in every case. Treatment decisions depend primarily on the patient’s clinical condition.
Does exercise help with knee osteoarthritis?
Yes. Appropriate strengthening and aerobic exercise are core treatments for knee osteoarthritis. They can improve function and reduce symptoms.
Can rehabilitation help with persistent shoulder pain?
Yes. Exercise-based treatment can improve shoulder function and reduce pain in many cases. The choice of treatment depends on the diagnosis and the cause of symptoms.
How long should rehabilitation take before considering surgery?
There is no single answer for every condition. The time needed to assess treatment depends on the diagnosis, symptom severity, programme and individual response. Agree a plan and review dates with the professional managing your care.
Is rehabilitation worth considering before surgery?
Rehabilitation can be an effective alternative to surgery for certain conditions, but it does not replace an individual diagnosis.
The ESCAPE and FIDELITY trials challenge the routine use of partial meniscus removal for many degenerative tears. FIMPACT found no additional benefit from a specific shoulder operation compared with sham surgery or exercise therapy.
Clinical guidelines also emphasise the role of exercise in treating non-specific low back pain and knee osteoarthritis.
The main takeaway is simple:
You do not always need to repair every change seen on an MRI to regain function.
Sources and further reading
- Noorduyn JCA et al. (2022). Effect of Physical Therapy vs Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy in People With Degenerative Meniscal Tears: Five-Year Follow-up of the ESCAPE Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Network Open.
- Sihvonen R et al. (2020). Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy for a degenerative meniscus tear: a 5 year follow-up of the placebo-surgery controlled FIDELITY trial. British Journal of Sports Medicine.
- Kanto K et al. (2025). Arthroscopic subacromial decompression versus placebo surgery for subacromial pain syndrome: 10 year follow-up of the FIMPACT trial. BMJ.
- NICE. Low back pain and sciatica in over 16s: assessment and management (NG59).
- NICE. Osteoarthritis in over 16s: diagnosis and management (NG226).
- Kesikburun B et al. (2019). Spontaneous regression of extruded lumbar disc herniation: correlation with clinical outcome.
- NICE. Suspected neurological conditions: recognition and referral (NG127), recommendations for adults aged over 16.
Get moving again with Forma
If your doctor or physiotherapist has recommended non-surgical care, regularly following an appropriate exercise programme may be an important part of returning to activity.
Explore Forma to plan and follow exercise programmes.
Forma helps organise exercise and track completion. It does not replace medical assessment or an individual decision about whether rehabilitation is appropriate.
Explore Forma